Sarah N. Dimmich in a denim jacket, hands on her hips

Dimmich Litigation

Trial counsel  ·  Indiana state and federal courts

Twenty-three years of defense litigation, tried in Indiana's state and federal courts. One lawyer on the file, from the first call after an incident through the verdict.

The short version

One lawyer on your file.

Sarah N. Dimmich in a black dress and pearls, seated on a white cube

Running my own shop lets me be exactly who I am as a lawyer. It also gives me full control over the day-to-day decisions and the overhead, and I keep the overhead low on purpose. My income rises and falls with my own effort and talent, which is one of the things I love most about running my own firm.

Indiana is where I try cases, and I've appeared for the case in courts outside it as well. Most of my clients are companies and the claims professionals and in-house lawyers who answer for them. The rest are small business owners and individuals who have no claims department to call, so they call me.

A long stretch of that career has been railroad defense, and it still is a large part of the docket. It gets a page of its own because it's by far the niche I know best.

Where to start

Most calls fall into one of three areas.

Railroads

Railroad defense

FELA claims, grade crossing and trespasser cases, FRSA whistleblower suits, spoliation fights, and on-scene incident response. Two decades of it, for carriers large and short line.

Everything else

Defense litigation generally

State university defense, catastrophic injury and wrongful death, preservation disputes, and employment law consulting.

Sarah N. Dimmich shaking hands with Dean Norman Lefstein at her 2002 law school commencement
Commencement, 2002, with Dean Norman Lefstein

Experience

My background.

Growing up

I grew up on a farm in Benton County, Indiana, with my parents and three sisters. My dad farmed with his brother, and my mom was a homemaker. We later moved to Lafayette, and I graduated from Harrison High School in West Lafayette before going to Purdue.

Supreme Court clerkship

After I graduated from the Indiana University McKinney School of Law, I clerked for Justice Brent E. Dickson of the Indiana Supreme Court.

Trial experience

I've tried twelve jury trials as first chair. Eleven were for defendants, and nine of those ended in a defense verdict.

State and federal court

I've tried cases in five Indiana counties and in four divisions of Indiana's two federal districts.

General information about how these files get worked. Not legal advice, and not a prediction about any particular case.