← All articles

Why Your Defense Team (Not a Vendor) Should Collect Plaintiff’s Medical Records

By Sarah N. Dimmich, Dimmich Litigation, LLC

If you hire outside counsel to defend your company in personal injury or Federal Employers’ Liability Act (FELA) cases, you may have looked at a bill, seen hours or days spent collecting medical records, and wondered whether you could save money by asking your lawyers to outsource that work. Having defended personal injury and FELA cases for more than 20 years, I think that would be a mistake. Plaintiff and defense firms alike are increasingly handing the job to vendors. These companies are popping up out of the woodwork; I get calls and ads from them weekly. I understand why it might be tempting to use one. I’ve seen it both ways: I’ve been brought into defense teams close to trial where an outside vendor gathered the plaintiff’s records, and I’ve spent my entire career collecting them myself with my own staff. I can tell you firsthand that letting your attorney and his or her staff collect the records will almost always yield a better result at trial.

The work is tedious, and that is the point

Every medical office has its own rules and quirks. One wants a particular form, another wants the request faxed, and a third wants payment first. Miss one of those requirements and the office either ignores you or makes the process miserable. Depending on the size of a practice, collecting records can be the full-time job of one or more paralegals. It is detail work, and it rewards people who care about the details.

When you see those hours on a bill, that is what you are buying: the knowledge of a staff member who has learned which office wants what, and who knows whom to call when a request goes quiet.

More important, your lawyer’s office is far less likely to give up when a provider will not cooperate right away and it takes two or three rounds of requests to get the records. Records tend to come to whoever keeps asking, and a vendor working through a stack of requests rarely has the stake in your case to keep at it.

Nobody sends the whole file

Even the most thorough request never brings back the complete chart. I used to pride myself on writing an ironclad request for records, using a numbered list, bold font, yellow highlights. I thought, “There’s no way it won’t be clear that I want THE WHOLE, ENTIRE, EVERY PAGE, EVERY FOOTNOTE, RECORD.” Then lo and behold, as I’m deposing the doctor, he grabs a manila file folder out of the plaintiff’s chart, flips to its inside cover, and starts reading from it. Had I thought to ask for the inside covers of the file folders themselves? Um, no. And lesson learned.

Actually, the lesson is that we’ll almost never get the whole file, no matter how hard we try. And most of the time, it probably won’t make a difference to the case.

But in my experience, if there’s a “make or break” sentence in a file, 7 out of 10 times, it’s going to be in a medical record. (2 out of 10 will be in a social media post, but that’s a different article).

The business model of these vendors is a conveyor belt, built for efficiency. If a vendor charges $30 per provider, for example, it treats the job as finished the moment it can check a box saying the records are in hand. For a careful defense lawyer, records in hand from a provider is where the real work begins.

As I read a plaintiff’s medical record, I find a logged phone call with no corresponding document, a reference to imaging, lab work, a pharmacy, another chiropractor, or a therapist. Each one starts a second round of authorizations and subpoenas. A vendor working through a checklist is unlikely to read the record closely enough to catch the missing piece. A lawyer or paralegal who knows the case – and who cares enough about getting a good outcome at trial to keep digging – will.

Doing it right can take six months to assemble a full medical picture of a plaintiff.

That timeline also drives when I take the plaintiff’s deposition. I do not depose a plaintiff until I have at least 90% of the known medical records, so that I can question the plaintiff with the records in front of me.

I push back on “no records”

When a facility says it has no records for a plaintiff and I am confident the plaintiff was seen there, I do not accept the answer. My staff call, email, and write until we either get the records or understand why they do not exist. Persistence is part of the job. If necessary, we ask that the request be escalated to the facility’s legal department, or we send a subpoena duces tecum to the doctor we believe the plaintiff saw there, commanding the doctor to bring the file to the deposition.

Plaintiffs do not volunteer the whole list

I know some defense firms make little effort to collect the plaintiff’s medical records and are content with the copies plaintiff’s counsel provides. If you hire defense counsel for these cases, insist that your lawyers get their own set, and make getting as full a set as possible a priority. A set assembled by the other side is only as complete as the other side chooses to make it.

No plaintiff has ever listed all of their medical providers in response to my client’s interrogatory asking for the complete list. When a plaintiff names five or more, I consider myself lucky. I start with those providers and, where the jurisdiction allows, have the plaintiff sign an authorization for each. I list each individual provider and each practice name.

That second part matters. In one case, the plaintiff denied ever seeing a chiropractor. I did not believe him, so I had him sign an authorization for every chiropractor in his town, and, to my surprise, he did so without objection. Every office came back saying, ”No records.” One of those offices had received an authorization naming the only doctor I knew worked there, and it told me the truth as far as it went: it had no records under that doctor’s name. Later, after I filed a motion to compel on a different subject, the plaintiff admitted that he had, in fact, treated at a local chiropractic practice and gave me his doctor’s name. It was not the doctor on my release. It was another doctor in the same office. Once the authorization named the practice and the doctor he had actually seen, I got the records, which evidenced pre-existing problems.

Why it matters

In my experience, a plaintiff’s medical records help the defense more than they help the plaintiff. In the cases I have tried, I am usually the one showing the jury most of the records. They reveal pre-existing conditions and failures to follow treatment recommendations. Missed physical therapy sessions don’t go over well with juries. Same with tests the doctor ordered, such as a renal ultrasound or a functional capacity exam, that the plaintiff never bothered to get. Taking a jury methodically through those details is worth the effort.

In one of my admitted-liability FELA cases, the plaintiff had back surgery after a derailment in which another train struck his parked train. After working through the process above, I found the fine-print nurse’s notes on page 983 of his medical records where the plaintiff explained he had needed the surgery for years (pre-injury) and had been putting it off. The day I found that sentence in the record, I actually went to dinner and celebrated with my husband, because I knew I had found a feasible path to a defense verdict in the case. That record was the key evidence, and the jurors confirmed it when I spoke with them afterward.

Where AI helps

The days of me having to read 983-page medical files are behind us, thank God. While I still pore over records, I now use Claude to do a first pass, interpret billing codes, keep my subpoena logs current, and flag gaps, such as a referenced test with no result or a provider who appears in one chart and nowhere else (i.e., someone I need to request records from). I store, summarize, and hyperlink the records in LawPro, which lets me move from a summary straight to the source page. These tools speed up the work. The judgment about what is missing and who to chase still comes from reading the record.

A word about cost

You may wonder whether this is worth the cost of having lawyers and paralegals do it when a vendor can do it for less.

First of all, I’m not convinced that using a vendor actually does cost less. These companies are expensive, and their services vary widely. Many of them still leave much of the legwork to the attorney, who has to decide which providers to list, get the authorizations signed, read what comes back to see what is missing, follow up when an office says it has no records, and prepare a subpoena when an office will not cooperate. When that is the arrangement, you are paying for the vendor and for your lawyer’s time as well.

A vendor delivers records. Reading them closely, and chasing everything that is missing from them, is what turns a stack of paper into a defense.

In the FELA case I described, one sentence on page 983 decided how I tried it. Nobody working from a checklist would have been looking for that sentence. The hours my staff and I spend are small next to the cost of trying or settling a case without knowing what the medical records would have shown.

The bottom line

Medical records are where I find the sentence that decides a case, and I have never found it by outsourcing the reading. So the next time you see those hours on a bill, realize that it’s time well spent working up the file. If your lawyer’s office outsources the job, perhaps it has found an amazing company. It’s definitely worth a conversation.